There is something pretty wild brewing in Asia right now and America’s closest allies are getting nervous. Trump is due to meet Xi Jinping and Putin on November 19 in Shenzhen. This would be the first time that leaders of the US, China and Russia have met like this in modern times.
The White House is saying it’s gonna be just about nuclear disarmament — pretty down the line stuff. But Trump has been talking his head off before going to the Philippines. Honestly, the whole thing of him standing there with these two authoritarian leaders has people from Brussels all the way to Tokyo feeling uneasy about what might actually happen.
“We know that every time President Trump talks to or sees Putin, it translates into bad news for Ukraine and for Europe. We brace for anything.” — European diplomat
Why Did Trump’s Departure Remarks Rattle U.S. Officials and Allies?
On Friday, senior U.S. officials sought to lower expectations in a briefing with reporters, insisting the trilateral summit would focus strictly on nuclear stockpiles and would not address the war in Ukraine. Chinese officials echoed that message.
Yet before boarding Air Force One for Manila on Monday, Trump undercut his own aides’ script:
- Denuclearization Skepticism: Trump reiterated that nuclear disarmament is his top goal, while openly acknowledging the uphill battle: “It’s very hard for any of us to say we’ll get rid of our nukes, right?” Neither Beijing nor Moscow had been eager to discuss nuclear limits; China only agreed after direct Russian lobbying.
- Putting Ukraine Back on the Table: Directly contradicting Friday’s White House guidance, Trump told reporters, “We’ll talk about my favorite subject, Ukraine,” adding that Iran would also come up (“We have Iran in very good shape, but we’ll talk about Iran a little bit”). For Putin, who pushed for the summit, the meeting represents a prime opportunity to lobby Trump directly on Ukraine.
- Floating a Kim Jong Un Reunion: Adding another layer of unpredictability, Trump also floated the possibility of a public meeting with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un during his Asia swing.
Why Are Both Europe and Japan Warning Against a “Yalta II”?
Behind closed doors, allies on two continents fear that an unscripted Trump could make unilateral concessions on territorial sovereignty—or project an image of three superpowers carving up the globe into spheres of influence.
In European capitals, diplomats are openly invoking “Yalta II”—a reference to the February 1945 summit where Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin decided the postwar fate of Eastern Europe without the nations affected in the room.
- Europe’s Warning in Dublin: At a closed-door gathering of European leaders in Dublin last week, anxiety over what Trump might say about Ukraine dominated private discussions. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz was among the most vocal participants before stepping outside to issue a public plea to Washington: “Our message to the U.S. before Trump meets Putin is: No surprises, please.” Ukrainian officials have echoed that exact concern.
- Tokyo’s Alarm Over Taiwan and North Korea: Across the Pacific, Japanese officials have privately relayed worries to their U.S. counterparts about what a Trump-Xi-Putin stage signals regarding Washington’s commitment to Taiwan and broader Indo-Pacific security. For Tokyo, a potential public reunion between Trump and Kim Jong Un would be even more destabilizing, risking the legitimization of North Korea’s nuclear program without allied coordination.
Split-Screen Diplomacy: What Happens in Berlin While Trump Meets Xi and Putin?
To prevent allies from being sidelined—and to separate Ukraine negotiations from the trilateral spectacle—the Trump administration is running a parallel diplomatic track on the exact same day.
| Diplomatic Track | Key Participants | Core Objective | Current Roadblock |
| Shenzhen Trilateral Summit (Same Day) | Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin | Discuss nuclear disarmament, Iran, and potentially Ukraine | Trump going off-script on Ukraine or Taiwan; “spheres of influence” optics |
| Berlin Allied Coordination (Same Day) | Jared Kushner, Steve Witkoff, plus senior officials from Ukraine, Germany, France, UK, Italy, Poland, EU, and NATO | Align Western security guarantees and postwar recovery plans ahead of Abu Dhabi talks | Deep European skepticism over whether Russia is negotiating in good faith |
| Abu Dhabi Peace Talks (Following Week) | U.S., Ukrainian, and Russian delegations (proposed European track) | Direct engagement on ending the war and a Europe-Russia security framework | Kremlin dispute: Moscow denies agreeing to European seats at the table |
The White House vs. Kremlin Clash Over Europe’s Seat at the Table
Ahead of the Berlin meeting, Trump’s special envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff held virtual consultations on Monday with Ukrainian and European representatives to lay the groundwork for direct dialogue with Moscow.
“We discussed how to facilitate direct engagement between Europe and Russia, which has been largely absent over the past four years. It is important that both sides hear each other’s concerns and proposals directly as we work toward a more stable and secure future for Europe.” — Jared Kushner, via X
However, a sharp contradiction quickly emerged between Washington and Moscow following Kushner and Witkoff’s separate Monday call with Kremlin foreign policy adviser Yuri Ushakov:
- What the White House Claims: U.S. officials stated that Putin had agreed to allow European representatives to join upcoming Ukraine negotiations in Abu Dhabi and to launch a parallel track of talks on a broader Europe-Russia security deal.
- What Moscow Says: Ushakov flatly disputed the White House’s account, stating that no such agreement had been reached.
That lingering dispute is a microcosm of the dilemma facing Washington’s allies as Trump prepares to take the world stage alongside Xi and Putin: Will the administration’s split-screen diplomacy forge a unified Western front, or compel Europe and Asia to react to surprises made behind closed doors?



